What happens in the Amish community when a young woman becomes pregnant before marriage.
My name is Sarah and I grew up within an Amish community in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. Before I get into the central topic, I need to share something that marked a before and after in my way of seeing the world in which I grew up.
When I was 17, my childhood friend, Rebecca, disappeared for eight months. It was not a move, nor a trip, nor an illness. He simply ceased to be there. When he returned, no one could talk about it. No one asked questions. That absolute silence was the first crack that made me understand that there were truths that were not said, but that weighed more than any word.
That silence is exactly what I want to talk about today.
Purity as an identity and social value
From a very young age, Amish girls grow up with a deep-rooted idea: our body is sacred and our purity is everything. It is not just a religious teaching, it is a way of defining the value of a woman within the community.
From the age of 12 I understood that my virginity was directly linked to my future: as a wife, as a member of the church and as a respectable person. There was no formal sex education. We learned about reproduction by watching animals on the farm. The message was simple and forceful: wait until marriage or face the consequences.
But there’s one thing few people outside of these communities understand: the Amish are human, too.
Rumspringa: limited freedom and hidden risks
During the period known as Rumspringa, which begins around the age of 16, Amish youth have more freedom. Nights out, barn parties, alcohol, sometimes drugs, and emotional relationships are all part of this stage.
The difference is that there is no access to contraceptive methods, there is no information about safe practices and, most seriously, there is no one to talk to without fear. When a pregnancy occurs, the problem is no longer just personal: it becomes a community affair.
The possible consequences: there is no single path
When a young Amish woman becomes pregnant before marriage, her fate depends on many factors: the reputation of her family, how strict the community is, whether the baby’s father is Amish or not, and in many cases, simply luck.
1. The hasty marriage
This is the scenario that the community prefers. If you’re both Amish and the families agree, the marriage is arranged in a matter of days or weeks. The pregnancy is disguised as an “anticipated” birth, and although the rumor persists for years, life goes on.
2. When the father is not Amish
If the parent is an “English” (non-Amish) youth, the situation becomes much more complicated. The pressure for him to convert or disappear is enormous. I knew cases of men who tried to adapt, but gave up after a short time. The young woman is left alone, carrying the responsibility and stigma.
3. Be sent away
This is the hardest and quietest option. Some families send their pregnant daughters to live “with relatives” in other states or to homes for single mothers run by Mennonite communities. There they spend their pregnancies, give birth and, in many cases, are forced to give their babies up for adoption.
That’s what happened to Rebecca.
She gave birth to a baby girl, held her for just a few minutes, and never saw her again. The adoption was closed. He does not know his daughter’s name. Upon returning to his community, he was expected to act as if nothing had happened.
4. Raising the Child Within the Community
Some more open families allow the young woman to stay and raise her child. But the price is high: it is highly unlikely that she will remarry within the community. The mother and child live in a kind of social limbo, always marked by a mistake that no one names, but everyone remembers.
5. Desperate decisions
There is a reality that almost no one mentions: some young women seek to terminate their pregnancies clandestinely. Without access to safe health care and information, the consequences can be severe. Cases are covered up as “medical emergencies” and the truth is buried along with shame.
The emotional weight that no one sees
The psychological damage of these experiences is profound and long-lasting. There is no therapy, there are no support groups, there are no spaces to talk. Only prayer, work and silence.
Meanwhile, men rarely face significant consequences. A talk with the elders of the church, perhaps a public confession, and life goes on. They can marry, start families, and keep their place in the community. Women carry the physical, social, and emotional marks for life.
What I learned when I left
After leaving the Amish community, I spent years in therapy trying to disarm the guilt, shame, and culture of purity that had been instilled in me. I understood that this system does not seek to protect women, but to control them through fear and reputation.
Faith and traditions may have valuable aspects, but when compassion is replaced by chastisement and silence, something is deeply broken.
The way pregnant Amish girls are treated out of wedlock has nothing to do with morality or spirituality. It has to do with power, control, and the preservation of a system that prioritizes appearance over human well-being.
👉 Follow our page, like 👍, and share this post. Every click can make a difference—perhaps saving your own life or that of a loved one.